“Old Flame” is a song about the thoughts that can remain after a relationship has ended. It was written by Sody and Martin Luke Brown and produced by Brown and Joe Kearns. The song is about that common feeling of wondering about your exes, do they think of you, do they talk about the past, and are they doing well? These questions can come at strange times, especially if you still have the memories of the good times with you. Sody speaks to the topic in a candid, down-to-earth voice, confessing how difficult it is to truly get over a relationship.
But the story turns again in the song: these lingering questions are harder to rationalize, especially since the narrator was the one who ended the relationship. It’s a contradictory detail to “Old Flame,” in that someone who’s decided to move on would still be curious about what happened next. As an added bonus, the track also ties in with the narrative of Sody’s last song, “What We Had,” so it feels like a continuation of those thoughts on love and its aftermath. Sody doesn’t pretend that a break-up makes all the feelings disappear, but she does look at the awkward, sometimes funny, reality of remembering an ex. “Old Flame” is about the temptation of old memories and the questions that can linger even when you know the relationship is over.